| Hint | Player | More Info |
| 1870s-1900s-1st great baseball slugger, HOF | |
| 1870s-1900s-Orator Jim, HOF | |
| 1880s-1910s-Black Sox Mgr 1919 | |
| 1880s-1910s-26 seasons, catcher | |
| 1880s-1910s-informally banned from baseball for Lajoie-Cobb batting championship scandal | |
| 1880s-1910s-No relation to Tom Clancy | |
| 1890s-1930s-5 decades-vaudeville routine w/ Al Schacht | |
| 1900s-1930s-Part of A's $100K infield, HOF | |
| 1900s-1930s-oldest to start WS game | |
| 1920s-1950s-only player mentioned in Ogden Nash's Lineup for Yesterday-Not in the HOF | |
| 1930s-1960s-1st mgr for new ('61) Senators | |
| 1930s-1960s-also managed Senators, HOF | |
| 1930s-1960s-debut for orig Senators, HOF | |
| 1940s-1980s-5 decades-last AB, 5-3 (grd out) for White Sox, played for Senators 1963 | |
| 1950s-1980s-16 gold gloves, debut w/ orig Senators | |
| 1950s-1980s-Norm Chad said, 'when you ask him the time, will tell you how a watch works.' | |
| | Hint | Player | More Info |
| 1950s-1980s-Most famous body of water in baseball, HOF | |
| 1960s-1990s-Fred Merkle of his day | |
| 1960s-1990s-Think Babe Ruth & rain delays | |
| 1960s-1990s-reversed his uniform number when traded, HOF | |
| 1960s-1990s-threw no-hitter | |
| 1960s-1990s-think Advil & barn, HOF | |
| 1970s-2000s-finished career w/ Calif Surf Dogs 2005, HOF | |
| 1970s-2000s-12 MLB teams | |
| 1970s-2000s-Pitcher for final out of a WS | |
| 1980s-2009-Flash! | |
| 1980s-2010-Mariner, HOF-lock | |
| 1980s-2009-RETIRED-Former Mariner, HOF-lock | |
| 1980s-2010-Another Former Mariner | |
| 1980s-2009-Dwight Gooden's nephew, HOF-poss | |
| 1980s-2009-think Doyle Alexander, HOF-poss | |
| 1980s-2010-Yet Another Former Mariner, HOF-poss | |
|