| Musical | Actor | Year |
| Angel in the Wings | |
| Where's Charley? | |
| South Pacific | |
| Guys and Dolls | |
| Top Banana | |
| Hazel Flagg | |
| Kismet | |
| Fanny | |
| Damn Yankees | |
| My Fair Lady | |
| The Music Man | |
| Redhead | |
| Take Me Along | |
| Camelot | |
| How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying | |
| A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | |
| Foxy | |
| Fiddler on the Roof | |
| Man of La Mancha | |
| I Do! I Do! | |
| The Happy Time | |
| | Musical | Actor | Year |
| Promises, Promises | |
| Purlie | |
| The Rothschilds | |
| A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum (revival) | |
| Pippin | |
| Cyrano | |
| Shenandoah | |
| My Fair Lady (revival) | |
| The Robber Bridegroom | |
| On the Twentieth Century | |
| Sweeney Todd | |
| Barnum | |
| The Pirates of Penzance | |
| Dreamgirls | |
| My One and Only | |
| La Cage aux Folles | |
| The Mystery of Edwin Drood | |
| Me and My Girl | |
| The Phantom of the Opera | |
| Jerome Robbins' Broadway | |
| City of Angels | |
| | Musical | Actor | Year |
| Miss Saigon | |
| Jelly's Last Jam | |
| Kiss of the Spider Woman | |
| She Loves Me (revival) | |
| How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (revival) | |
| A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum (revival) | |
| Chicago (revival) | |
| Cabaret (revival) | |
| Little Me | |
| Kiss Me, Kate (revival) | |
| The Producers | |
| Sweet Smell of Success | |
| Hairspray | |
| The Boy From Oz | |
| Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | |
| Jersey Boys | |
| Curtains | |
| South Pacific (revival) | |
| Billy Elliot (three people won this year for sharing the part of Billy Elliot) | |
| La Cage aux Folles (revival) | |
| Catch Me If You Can | |
|