| Clue | Answer |
|---|
| What was John's position in the military | |
| Who was in possession of the colt before the Winchesters | |
| What Steve McQueen movie is referenced in 'The Usual Suspects' (Hint: Steve McQueen is not in the Usual Suspects) | |
| What is Sam and Dean's grandfathers name? | |
| What cartoon was playing in the airplane that Sam and Dean were transported to in 'Sympathy for the Devil' | |
| What form does the garden take when Sam and Dean visit Joshua in heaven | |
| What was the ironic name of the doctor paged in 'In My Time Dying' | |
| What was Chuck's pen name for the 'Supernatural' series | |
| What school did Sam attend before joining Dean to find their dad | |
| Deans porno mag of choice | |
| The bartender in 'Sin City' makes Dean what kind of a drink | |
| Why do people wear masks on Halloween | |
| What type of horse does War ride | |
The Princess Bride 
Monty Python Holy Grail 
L.D. Things
