| Clue | Answer |
| The bartender in 'Sin City' makes Dean what kind of a drink | |
| What form does the garden take when Sam and Dean visit Joshua in heaven | |
| What was the first seal broken | |
| What Steve McQueen movie is referenced in 'The Usual Suspects' (Hint: Steve McQueen is not in the Usual Suspects) | |
| In 'Mystery Spot' what song woke same every morning | |
| What is Sam and Dean's grandfathers name? | |
| Who was in possession of the colt before the Winchesters | |
| What state was the last seal broken and Lucifer released | |
| What is the name of Lucifers temporary 'vessel' | |
| What do Sam and Dean have to prevent them from being possessed by demons | |
| When Dean was in Hell, what did Sam add to the Impala | |
| In 'Nightshifter' what did Ron think the shapeshifter was | |
| What was the ironic name of the doctor paged in 'In My Time Dying' | |