| Location | Challenger | Date |
| Philidelphia, PA (won title) | |
| Cambridge, MA | |
| Montreal, Quebec, Canada | |
| Serbing, FL | |
| Elizabeth, NJ (Steel Cage) | |
| Chicago Ridge, IL | |
| Weesen, Switzerland | |
| Krems, Austria (Triple Threat) | |
| Krems, Austria (Triple Threat) | |
| Lakeland, FL | |
| Serbing, FL | |
| Asbury Park, NJ | |
| Dorchester, MA (Draw) | |
| New York, NY | |
| Dayton, OH | |
| Chicago Ridge, IL | |
| Tulancingo, Mexico (Triple Threat) | |
| Tulancingo, Mexico (Triple Threat) | |
| Buffalo, NY | |
| Morristown, NJ (Lost title) | |
| | Location | Challenger | Date |
| New York, NY (Won title) | |
| Chicago Ridge, IL | |
| Toronto Ontario Canada (Four Way Match) | |
| Toronto Ontario Canada (Four Way Match) | |
| Toronto Ontario Canada (Four Way Match) | |
| Philidelphia, PA | |
| Philidelphia, PA | |
| Philidelphia, PA | |
| Chicago Ridge, IL | |
| New York, NY | |
| Collinsville, IL | |
| Philadelphia, PA (Four Way Match) | |
| Philadelphia, PA (Four Way Match) | |
| Philadelphia, PA (Four Way Match) | |
| Novi, MI | |
| Mississauga, Ontario, Canada | |
| Chicago Ridge, IL (Cage Match) | |
| New York, NY (Draw) | |
| New York, NY (Lost title) | |
|