| Hint | Villain |
| Jason Todd/Joker's first alias | |
| Jonathan Crane | |
| Dumfrey and Deever Tweed | |
| Arnold Wesker/Peyton Riley | |
| Arnold and Peyton's puppet | |
| Cyrus Gold | |
| He tallys his kills on his skin. | |
| Joseph Meach | |
| Leader of the Falcone crime family | |
| Leader of the Maroni crime family | |
| More Superman's enemy, really. | |
| Thomas Wayne Jr. (Earth-3)/Roy Raymond Jr. | |
| Humphrey Dumpler | |
| Main villain in Final Crisis. | |
| Simon Hurt | |
| Slade Wilson | |
| Lonnie Machin | |
| Lazlo Valentin | |
| The Bizarro version of Batman. | |
| Dr. Linda Friitawa | |
| Garfield Lynns | |
| Arthur Brown | |
| Anatoli Knyazev | |
| Alfred Pennyworth | |
| Writer of All Star Batman and Robin | |
| Only appears in Batman & Dracula: Red Rain | |
| Only appeared in Batman: Arkham Asylum | |
| Ridley Scott's famous creation | |
| Alien famous for its dreadlocks. | |
| Loki's mask, once worn by the late Stanley Ipkiss. | |