| where they are/were | | Clue |
| Went to prison in the 80s | |
| Became alleged murderer, famous for car chase | |
| Shoe store Employee | |
| Approaching 40, no sport-related job | |
| Fourth string QB for Toronto Argonauts | |
| Suffered from moral dilemmas leading to a dangerous path | |
| Was in prison, then a dentist | |
| ESPN, but before that bounced around CFL | |
| backup NFL QB | |
| Was a XFL running back | |