| Top Two finishers | Winner |
| Doc Blanchard or Glenn Davis? | |
| Charles Woodson or Peyton Manning? | |
| Terry Baker or Jerry Stovall? | |
| Chuck Long or Bo Jackson? | |
| Charlie Justice or Doak Walker? | |
| Billy Lothridge or Roger Staubach? | |
| Pat Sullivan or Ed Marinaro? | |
| Anthony Thompson or Andre Ware? | |
| Paul Giel or John Lattner? | |
| Troy Davis or Danny Weurffel? | |
| Alan Ameche or Kurt Burris? | |
| Paul Governali or Frank Sinkwich? | |
| Gino Torretta or Marshall Faulk? | |
| John Huarte or Jerry Rhome? | |
| Ty Detmer or Raghib Ismail? | |
| Randy Duncan or Pete Dawkins? | |
| Charlie Justice or Leon Hart? | |
| Herschel Walker or Marcus Allen? | |
| Tim Brown or Don McPherson? | |
| Rodney Peete or Barry Sanders? | |
| Jason White or Larry Fitzgerald? | |
| Terry Miller or Earl Campbell? | |
| Bob Griese or Steve Spurrier? | |
| Tom Brown or Joe Bellino? | |
| Anthony Davis or Archie Griffin? | |