| Year- Team, League | Player | Batting Average-Homeruns-RBIs |
| 1887- St. Louis, AA | |
| 1894- Boston, NL | |
| 1901- Philadelphia, AL | |
| 1909- Detroit, AL | |
| 1922- St. Louis, NL | |
| 1925- St. Louis, NL | |
| 1933- Philadelphia, AL | |
| 1933- Philadelphia, NL | |
| | Year- Team, League | Player | Batting Average-Homeruns-RBIs |
| 1934- New York, AL | |
| 1937- St. Louis, NL | |
| 1942- Boston, AL | |
| 1947- Boston, AL | |
| 1956- New York, AL | |
| 1966- Baltimore, AL | |
| 1967- Boston, AL | |
|