| Year/Team | Player | Number of Times |
| 1991, 2007 - Pit, SF | |
| 1991, 2003 - CWS | |
| 1996, 2006 - Cle, Phi, CWS | |
| 1999, 2005 - Phi | |
| 1996, 2002 - Hou | |
| 2002, 2009 - Cin, Ari, Was | |
| 1999, 2006 - Oak, NYY | |
| 1980, 1998 - Oak, NYY, Tor, SD | |
| 2000, 2006 - Pit, SD | |
| 2000, 2007 - Col | |
| 1990, 1999 - Oak, Stl | |
| 1992, 1997 - Det, Cal, CWS, Ana | |
| 1990, 1995 - Bal, Det, Tex | |
| 1986, 1989 - Bos | |
| 1987, 1990 - Stl, NYY, SD | |
| 2000, 2003 - Tor | |
| 1995, 1998 - Sea | |
| 1996, 2000 - Fla, LAD | |
| 2002, 2004 - Hou | |
| 1982, 1987 - Bos | |
| 1999, 2002 - Atl | |
| 1993, 2000 - Tor, NYM, Sea | |
| 2005, 2007 - Bos | |
| 2000, 2002 - Tex | |
| 2008, 2010 - Stl | |
| 1993, 1997 - Sea | |
| 2007, 2008 - Phi | |
| 2007, 2008 - Oak | |
| | Year/Team | Player | Number of Times |
| 2000, 2004 - Stl | |
| 2009, 2010 - Mil | |
| 2000, 2001 - Ana | |
| 2006, 2007 - Cle | |
| 1980, 1982 - Cle | |
| 1987, 1989 - Phi | |
| 2006, 2007 - Phi | |
| 1989, 1991 - Tor, SD | |
| 1982, 1983 - Phi | |
| 2001, 2002 - Cubs | |
| 2010 - Oak | |
| 2010 - Tor | |
| 2006 - Pit | |
| 1999 - Bal | |
| 1985 - KC | |
| 1991 - LAD | |
| 1988 - SF | |
| 2003 - SF | |
| 1993 - Phi | |
| 1989 - Sea | |
| 1987 - Cal | |
| 2004 - Atl | |
| 2003 - Oak | |
| 1993 - Phi | |
| 2006 - Hou | |
| 1987 - Det | |
| 2009 - Ana | |
| 2009 - SD | |
| | Year/Team | Player | Number of Times |
| 2001 - Ari | |
| 1985 - Tex | |
| 1982 - Stl | |
| 1999 - Oak | |
| 2006 - Was | |
| 1993 - Phi | |
| 1984 - Cubs | |
| 1992 - Bal | |
| 1987 - Atl | |
| 1984 - Bal | |
| 1996 - NYY | |
| 2007 - TB | |
| 2000 - NYY | |
| 2006 - Bos | |
| 1980 - NYY | |
| 1988 - Bal | |
| 2000 - Sea | |
| 2000 - Ana | |
| 1989 - KC | |
| 2007 - Cle | |
| 2007 - Oak | |
| 1992 - NYY | |
| 1982 - Pit | |
| 1982 - Cle | |
| 1993 - CWS | |
| 2004 - Mon | |
| 1999 - NYY | |
|