| A show about... | Title of Musical |
| Puppet neighbors learning about living as grown-ups | |
| The relationship between a brother and sister across two eras | |
| College students spending a terrifying weekend in an abandoned cabin (based on a film) | |
| Gordon Schwinn, the failed composer, struggling with a brain brain aneurysm | |
| The Charles Schultz's comic strip about a perpetual loser and his friends | |
| two guys writing a musical about two guys writing a musical about two guys writing a musical... | |
| two Catholic school boys discovering their sexuality and the troubles their relationship brings | |
| An East German transgender rock star | |
| An entrepreneurial high school cheerleader, based on the famous adult film of the same name | |
| A relationship, told forward and backwards from first meeting to divorce, intersecting at the marriage proposal | |
| A magical teen in a world where gay is the majority and being straight is taboo | |
| The death of the titular character, who is stuck in a cave he was exploring | |
| All the hit Broadway shows...their faults and funnies | |
| The life of composer who is struggling to write, love, and find his place as his 30th birthday approaches | |
| | A show about... | Title of Musical |
| A boy born in a cave many miles to the south with fangs in his mouth | |
| A girl born to entertain with dramatic stage mother in a send-up of female Broadway characters like Mame and Gypsy Rose. Ends in a bloodbath | |
| a revue tribute to 'guy groups', told by the re-encarnated victims of a tragic collision of buses on the way to the Ed Sullivan Show. | |
| a town where it's a privilege to pee | |
| a man struggling to paint a pointalist masterpiece and his lover's great-grandson struggling with his own art | |
| changes in life...a song cycle that showcases a fearless girl, a king of the world, and Betsy Ross | |
| a young Black musician rebelling against his middle-class LA family and going to Amsterdam where he pretends he comes from poverty to get ahead, passing from place to place. | |
| a musical revue of Sondheim songs, the title taken from the show in Question #19 of this quiz | |
| a very crazy night in New York City, based off a Joseph Moncure March poem of the same name | |
| a Catholic boy band | |
| rhythm! Musical using buckets, brooms, and anything else that can make a beat! | |
| exactly what the title says...boys in the buff | |
| a group of elementry school students participating in a competition about words | |
|