| Before Clue | Answer | After Clue |
| 2010 Ford C. Frick Award Recipient | |
| 1940s baseball movie | |
| Film about the Black Sox Scandal | |
| Outfielder traded with Cliff Lee from the Indians to the Phillies | |
| Pitcher who threw a perfect game--and a camera at a reporter | |
| Hall of Fame Pittsburgh Pirates player, first name constantly mispronounced | |
| Highly-praised baseball video game series, ended after 2005 | |
| Former Major League pitcher who won the 1982 World Series with the St. Louis Cardinals | |
| Former MLB pitcher, finished career with 288 wins after 25 seasons | |
| Former MLB outfielder, played 15 seasons, born in Dominican Republic | |
| | Before Clue | Answer | After Clue |
| Los Angeles Angels outfielder, noted for uncanny ability of robbing home runs | |
| Former MLB pitcher, pitched notably for Boston Red Sox; currently in NPB | |
| Hall of Fame second baseman, most notably part of the 'Big Red Machine' | |
| New York Mets catcher, played in independent leagues until age 33 | |
| Hall of Fame outfielder, held career record for home runs until 2007 | |
| Former MLB pitcher, played for Seattle Mariners three separate times and won World Series four times with the New York Yankees | |
| Former MLB pitcher who claims to have thrown no-hitter while high on LSD | |
| Former MLB second baseman, all-time leader in home runs amongst second basemen | |
| 2002 baseball movie starring Dennis Quaid | |
| Los Angeles Dodgers third baseman, acquired in 2008 from the Cleveland Indians | |
|