| Team, Years | Player | Points |
| Syracuse, 1991-95 | |
| Boston College, 1999-2003 | |
| Notre Dame, 2006-2010 | |
| Seton Hall, 1989-1993 | |
| St. Johns, 1981-1985 | |
| Villanova, 1992-1996 | |
| Boston College, 1985-89 | |
| St. Johns, 1994-98 | |
| Villanova, 2006-2010 | |
| Boston College, 1990-94 | |
| Providence, 2001-05 | |
| Syracuse, 1992-96 | |
| St. Johns, 1988-92 | |
| St. Johns, 1994-98 | |
| Boston College, 1993-97 | |
| Providence, 1987-91 | |
| Connecticut, 1988-92 | |
| Providence, 1995-99 | |
| Seton Hall, 1982-86 | |
| Notre Dame, 1995-98 | |
| Notre Dame, 2001-05 | |
| USF, 2007-10 | |
| Miami, 1995-99 | |
| | Team, Years | Player | Points |
| Miami, 2000-04 | |
| Seton Hall, 2007-present | |
| Pittsburgh, 1984-88 | |
| Cincinnati, 2006-10 | |
| Connecticut, 1996-99 | |
| Marquette, 2005-09 | |
| Syracuse, 1986-90 | |
| West Virginia, 2006-10 | |
| Villanova, 2002-06 | |
| Syracuse, 2002-06 | |
| Seton Hall, 1984-88 | |
| Connecticut, 1993-96 | |
| Notre Dame, 1998-01 | |
| Georgetown, 1983-87 | |
| Syracuse, 1982-86 | |
| Pittsburgh, 1997-01 | |
| Georgetown, 1988-92 | |
| Georgetown, 1981-85 | |
| Providence, 2005-10 | |
| Syracuse, 2001-05 | |
| Georgetown, 1992-96 | |
| Connecticut, 1991-94 | |
|