| Final 2009 Team | Player | Hall of Fame Monitor Score |
| Yankees | |
| Giants | |
| Yankees | |
| Mariners | |
| Cardinals | |
| Rangers | |
| Yankees | |
| Dodgers | |
| Phillies | |
| Mariners | |
| Angels | |
| Cardinals | |
| Brewers | |
| Braves | |
| Rockies | |
| Mets | |
| Astros | |
| | Final 2009 Team | Player | Hall of Fame Monitor Score |
| Dodgers | |
| Yankees | |
| Athletics | |
| Mets | |
| Tigers | |
| Red Sox | |
| Brewers | |
| Rangers | |
| Rockies | |
| Rangers | |
| Yankees | |
| Rangers | |
| Rays | |
| Giants | |
| Angels | |
| Red Sox | |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| You actually guessed Jose Mesa, really? Why? | |
| |
| |
| Astros | |
| Cardinals | |
| Phillies | |
| Mets | |
| Blue Jays | |
| Dodgers | |
| Mets | |
| Cubs | |
| Yankees | |
| Tigers | |
| Phillies | |
| Yankees | |
| Mets | |
| Astros | |
| Braves | |
| Twins | |
|