| Year | Pitcher | Wins |
| 1903 (Boston Americans) | |
| 1903 (Pittsburgh Pirates) | |
| 1903 (Boston Americans) | |
| 1905 (New York Giants) | |
| 1906 (Chicago White Sox) | |
| 1908 (Chicago Cubs) | |
| 1908 (Chicago Cubs) | |
| 1909 (Pittsburgh Pirates) | |
| 1909 (Detroit Tigers) | |
| 1910 (Philadelphia A's) | |
| 1911 (Philadelphia A's) | |
| 1912 (Boston Red Sox) | |
| 1912 (New York Giants) | |
| 1913 (Philadelphia A's) | |
| 1914 (Boston Braves) | |
| 1914 (Boston Braves) | |
| 1915 (Boston Red Sox) | |
| 1916 (Boston Red Sox) | |
| 1917 (Chicago White Sox) | |
| 1918 (Boston Red Sox) | |
| 1918 (Boston Red Sox) | |
| 1919 (Cincinnati Reds) | |
| 1919 (Chicago White Sox) | |
| 1920 (Cleveland Indians) | |
| 1921 (New York Giants) | |
| 1921 (New York Giants) | |
| 1921 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1923 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1924 (Washington Senators) | |
| 1925 (Pittsburgh Pirates) | |
| 1925 (Washington Senators) | |
| 1925 (Pittsburgh Pirates) | |
| 1926 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1926 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1926 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1928 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1930 (Philadelphia Athletics) | |
| 1930 (Philadelphia Athletics) | |
| 1931 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1931 (Philadelphia Athletics) | |
| | Year | Pitcher | Wins |
| 1931 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1933 (New York Giants) | |
| 1934 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1934 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1935 (Detroit Tigers) | |
| 1935 (Chicago Cubs) | |
| 1936 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1937 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1938 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1940 (Cincinnati Reds) | |
| 1940 (Detroit Tigers) | |
| 1940 (Cincinnati Reds) | |
| 1942 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1943 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1945 (Chicago Cubs) | |
| 1945 (Detroit Tigers) | |
| 1946 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1947 (Brooklyn Dodgers) | |
| 1947 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1948 (Cleveland Indians) | |
| 1951 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1952 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1952 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1955 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1955 (Brooklyn Dodgers) | |
| 1957 (Milwaukee Braves) | |
| 1958 (Milwaukee Braves) | |
| 1958 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1959 (Los Angeles Dodgers) | |
| 1960 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1960 (Pittsburgh Pirates) | |
| 1960 (Pittsburgh Pirates) | |
| 1961 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1962 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1963 (Los Angeles Dodgers) | |
| 1964 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1964 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1965 (Minnesota Twins) | |
| 1965 (Los Angeles Dodgers) | |
| 1967 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| | Year | Pitcher | Wins |
| 1967 (Boston Red Sox) | |
| 1968 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1968 (Detroit Tigers) | |
| 1969 (New York Mets) | |
| 1971 (Pittsburgh Pirates) | |
| 1971 (Baltimore Orioles) | |
| 1972 (Cincinnati Reds) | |
| 1972 (Oakland Athletics) | |
| 1973 (Oakland Athletics) | |
| 1975 (Cincinnati Reds) | |
| 1975 (Boston Red Sox) | |
| 1977 (New York Yankees) | |
| 1980 (Philadelphia Phillies) | |
| 1982 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1982 (Milwaukee Brewers) | |
| 1984 (Detroit Tigers) | |
| 1985 (Kansas City Royals) | |
| 1985 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
| 1986 (Boston Red Sox) | |
| 1987 (Minnesota Twins) | |
| 1988 (Los Angeles Dodgers) | |
| 1989 (Oakland Athletics) | |
| 1989 (Oakland Athletics) | |
| 1990 (Cincinnati Reds) | |
| 1991 (Minnesota Twins) | |
| 1992 (Toronto Blue Jays) | |
| 1992 (Toronto Blue Jays) | |
| 1995 (Atlanta Braves) | |
| 1997 (Florida Marlins) | |
| 1997 (Cleveland Indians) | |
| 2000 (New York Yankees) | |
| 2001 (Arizona Diamondbacks) | |
| 2003 (Florida Marlins) | |
| 2008 (Philadelphia Phillies) | |
| 2009 (Philadelphia Phillies) | |
| 2009 (New York Yankees) | |
| 2010 (San Francisco Giants) | |
| 2011 (St. Louis Cardinals) | |
|