| Year | Pitcher | Team |
| 2011 (NL 5, AL 1) | |
| 2010 (NL 3, AL 1) | |
| 2009 (AL 4, NL 3) | |
| 2008 (AL 4, NL 3) | |
| 2007 (AL 5, NL 4) | |
| 2006 (AL 3, NL 2) | |
| 2005 (AL 7, NL 5) | |
| 2004 (AL 9, NL 4) | |
| 2003 (AL 7, NL 6) | |
| 2001 (AL 4, NL 1) | |
| 2000 (AL 6, NL 3) | |
| 1999 (AL 4, NL 1) | |
| 1998 (AL 13, NL 8) | |
| 1997 (AL 3, NL 1) | |
| 1996 (NL 6, AL 0) | |
| 1995 (NL 3, AL 2) | |
| | Year | Pitcher | Team |
| 1994 (NL 8, AL 7) | |
| 1993 (AL 9, NL 3) | |
| 1992 (AL 13, NL 6) | |
| 1991 (AL 4, NL 2) | |
| 1990 (AL 2, NL 0) | |
| 1989 (AL 5, NL 3) | |
| 1988 (AL 2, NL 1) | |
| 1987 (NL 2, AL 0) | |
| 1986 (AL 3, NL 2) | |
| 1985 (NL 6, AL 1) | |
| 1984 (NL 3, AL 1) | |
| 1983 (AL 13, NL 3) | |
| 1982 (NL 4, AL 1) | |
| 1981 (NL 5, AL 4) | |
| 1980 (NL 4, AL 2) | |
|