| Description | Star |
| WR for the Cowboys during their 90's dynasty | |
| Broken neck ended his career in the early 90's for the Packers | |
| Leader of a dogfighting ring in the past | |
| Corked bat and steroid allegations for this slugger | |
| Member of the M&M boys in '61 that didn't break the record | |
| Most known for his NBA career and the HIV virus | |
| Led 'The Drive' at QB against the Browns | |
| First athlete to sign with IMG | |
| Highest paid MLB player | |
| First talented latin player in the history of the MLB | |
| First black player in the AL of the MLB | |
| Dodged the draft of the Vietnam War | |
| Rushed for 2000 yards and was drafted in the sixth round | |
| Only player to give back his Heisman | |
| Nicknamed the admiral | |
| Best player not on the Dream Team of '92 | |