| Nickname | Name | Years Played |
| Death to Flying Things | |
| Orator Jim | |
| Pebbly Jack | |
| Smiling Mickey | |
| The Freshest Man on Earth | |
| Grasshopper Jim | |
| Old Hoss | |
| The Apollo of the Box | |
| Parisian Bob | |
| Silent Mike | |
| Sliding Billy | |
| Eagle Eye | |
| The Hoosier Thunderbolt | |
| The Crab | |
| The Duke of Tralee | |
| | Nickname | Name | Years Played |
| The Flying Dutchman | |
| The Tobasco Kid | |
| The Peerless Leader | |
| Turkey Mike | |
| Wahoo Sam | |
| The Crab | |
| Miner | |
| The Mighty Mite | |
| The Georgia Peach | |
| The Big Train | |
| The Grey Eagle | |
| Shoeless Joe | |
| Home Run | |
| The Sultan of Swat | |
| The Fordham Flash | |
|