| School/Position | Player | Years honored |
| Army/Mississippi E | |
| Texas E | |
| Army FB | |
| Army HB | |
| California G | |
| Notre Dame E | |
| SMU HB | |
| Syracuse HB | |
| Georgia Tech DB | |
| USC LB | |
| Pittsburgh RB | |
| Ohio State RB | |
| Alabama LB | |
| | School/Position | Player | Years honored |
| Notre Dame TE | |
| Texas P | |
| UCLA LB | |
| UCLA DB | |
| Pittsburgh DE | |
| Michigan WR | |
| Georgia RB | |
| Pittsburgh OT | |
| San Diego State RB | |
| North Carolina DB | |
| Wisconsin RB | |
| Ohio State DB | |
| Georgia DE | |
| Yale G 1889-91 | |
| Princeton QB 1891-93 | |
| Harvard FB 1892-94 | |
| Princeton G 1892-94 | |
| Princeton T 1893-95 | |
| Pennsylvania E-G 1894-96 | |
| Harvard E 1899-1901 | |
| Yale E 1902, 1904-05 | |
| Yale T 1902-04 | |
| Chicago QB-E 1904-06 | |
| Yale FB 1907-09 | |
| Harvard G 1912-14 | |
| Harvard FB 1913-15 | |
| Pittsburgh C 1914-16 | |
| Ohio State HB 1916-17, 1919 | |
| Williams QB 1917, 1919-20 | |
| Washington & Jefferson T 1917-19 | |
| Syracuse G-C 1918-20 | |
| Centre QB 1919-21 | |
| Illinois HB 1923-25 | |
| Michigan E 1925-27 | |
| Army HB 1927-29 | |
| Ohio State E 1928-30 | |
| Washington State QB 1934-36 | |
| Texas Christian C 1934-36 | |
| Minnesota T 1934-36 | |
| Tennessee G 1938-40 | |
| Illinois/Purdue G 1942-43, 1946 | |
| Alabama/Navy T 1942-44 | |
|