| Clue | Answer | RIGHT!? |
| It's not Killfest | |
| How good we are | |
| The X-factor | |
| Chad's favorite appetizer | |
| Blue-finned justice? | |
| How often we play Monopoly | |
| A necessity during Come On Eileen | |
| Our source of common knowledge | |
| Formerly known as: | |
| The most commonly submitted PHT answer | |
| Quick Pink | |
| He would have rode the scooter around town | |
| Only man to ever have gotten a girl's number at PHT. | |
| Delivers the ranch | |
| Who ACTUALLY sings Play that Funky Music | |
| Breakdancing trivia rivals? | |
| Alternate team name used when only Colin, Drew, and Chad are present | |
| PHT God and Super Bowl XXXV Champion | |
| Receives extra ham every Monday | |
| The 2009 champion's team name in 2010 | |