| Hint | Character |
| Aggressive male reporter | |
| Wonderland-esque antagonist | |
| Green scaly antagonist (cameo) | |
| Clown antagonist | |
| Female reporter for Gotham News | |
| Dick Grayson | |
| One armed twins (last name) | |
| Short, chubby antagonist | |
| Obsessed with holidays | |
| Giant undead monster who can't die | |
| Childhood friend of Bruce Wayne | |
| Aspiring actor | |
| Mayor of Gotham City, Warden of Arkham Asylum | |
| Female playable character | |
| Female assassin and love interest to protagonist | |
| Mask obsessed antagonist (cameo) | |