| Hint | President | Eliminated Presidents |
| Born in the state of Hawaii | |
| Attended Harvard Law School | |
| Visited Puerto Rico as a sitting President | |
| Had a last name ending in 'Y' | |
| Buried in Arlington Cemetery | |
| Succeeded by a President Johnson | |
| Succeeded Grover Cleveland | |
| Elected directly from the Senate | |
| Assassinated in office | |
| Saw combat during the Civil War | |
| Served as a Republican in the 1800's | |
| Graduated from West Point | |
| Oversaw Reconstruction | |
| Died younger than 60 | |
| Served in the same administration as Nixon | |
| Shot while in office | |
| Was a Methodist | |
| Beat a candidate who won the popular vote | |
| Attained the rank of General | |
| Related to an earlier President | |
| Portrayed on a standard US coin | |
| Portrayed on Mount Rushmore | |