| Hint | Character | Number of Appearances |
| Former Robin who is now Red Robin | |
| Harvey Dent, enemy of Batman | |
| Titan formerly known as Aqualad | |
| Jo-Nah of the Legion of Super Heroes | |
| Second man to take the Blue Beetle moniker | |
| Legion member who is also called Star Boy | |
| The Starman of the Golden Age | |
| Daughter of Ra's Al Ghul and lover of Batman | |
| Inuit friend of Green Lantern | |
| Father of Batman | |
| Frontier freedom fighter of the Revolutionary War | |
| Serves as Johnny Thunder's back-up | |
| Member of the Teen Titans who loved Beast Boy | |
| Green Lantern from the planet Xudar | |
| Stuttering member of the Metal Men | |
| Leader of the Freedom Fighters who represents the Spirit of America | |
| James Jesse, former enemy of the Flash | |