| Hint | Character | Number of Appearances |
| Batman ally formerly known as Robin | |
| New God who is the son of Darkseid | |
| Scandinavian member of the Blackhawks | |
| Son of Green Lantern Alan Scott and member of the Justice Society of America | |
| Larry Trainor of the Doom Patrol | |
| Ally of Mister Miracle and Big Barda | |
| Brother and enemy of Aquaman | |
| | Hint | Character | Number of Appearances |
| Niece of Steel and member of Infinity Inc. | |
| Ally of Batman and member of Suicide Squad | |
| Legion of Substitute Heroes member Lydda Jath | |
| Freedom Fighters member formerly known as the Ray | |
| Went by the alias Captain Boomerang | |
| Kryptonian criminal and enemy of Superman | |
| Crime Syndicate's answer to Batman | |
|