| Hint | Character | Number of Appearances |
| Wife of Doctor Fate | |
| Son of the Golden Age Starman who became Starman for a while | |
| Enemy of Richard Dragon and Bronze Tiger | |
| Brother of Captain Marvel Jr. who can summon heroes from the past | |
| Enemy of Superman who was imprisoned in the Phantom Zone | |
| Drury Walker, enemy of Batman | |
| Member of the Female Furies who uses a lash | |
| Believed to be the Last Boy on Earth | |
| Jacques Foccart, successor to Lyle Norg | |
| Telepathic member of the Teen Titans | |
| Member of the Outsiders with psionic powers | |
| Enemy of Firestorm with ice powers | |
| Jeff Burr, leader of a terrorist cult | |
| Has control of a Thunderbolt after Johnny Thunder retired | |
| Enemy of Green Lantern from the Planet Maltus | |
| Murdered the parents of Batman | |
| Nanaue, an enemy of Superboy who is a humanoid shark | |
| Navajo pilot who joined the Losers | |
| Member of Stormwatch who uses quantum powers | |
| Zoe Saugin of the planet Aleph | |
| Member of the Legion of Super-Villains and enemy of Lightning Lad | |
| Member of the Green Lantern Corps from Thanagar | |