| Hint | Character | Number of Appearances |
| Batman's friend and father of Batgirl | |
| When Billy Batson says 'Shazam,' he becomes... | |
| Selina Kyle, former enemy of Batman | |
| Victor Stone of the Teen Titans | |
| One of three founders of the Legion of Super Heroes | |
| Legion of Super Heroes member from Durla | |
| Freddy Freeman, ally of Billy Batson | |
| Nathaniel Adam of the Justice League International | |
| Moonlights as a Star Sapphire | |
| Chilly enemy of the Flash | |
| Legion of Super Heroes member who can grow to enormous heights | |
| Identity of the Golden Age Doctor Mid-Nite | |
| Also known as Congo Bill | |
| Chinese member of the Blackhawks | |
| Served as Batgirl when Barbara Gordon became Oracle | |
| Flash villain from Australia | |
| Jack Ryder, ally of Batman | |
| Blackhawk from Texas | |
| Archenemy of Wonder Woman | |
| Niles Caulder, founder of the Doom Patrol | |
| | Hint | Character | Number of Appearances |
| Took over the Green Arrow mantle while his father was believed to be dead | |
| Enemies of Batman associated with shape-shifting | |
| Daily Planet employee whose son was murdered by Toyman | |
| Adam Blake, one of the first 1950s heroes | |
| Enemy of Wonder Woman associated with Odysseus' travels | |
| Hank Henshaw, enemy of Superman | |
| Green Lantern of Space Sector 1416 | |
| Became the third Spectre | |
| Member of the Seven Soldiers of Victory and one of the first members to die | |
| French member of the Justice League International and Global Guardians | |
| Thomas Blake, enemy of Batman | |
| Archenemy of the Atom | |
| Fought Batman, Atom, Black Canary, Hawkman, Green Arrow, and Elongated Man | |
| Archenemy of Green Arrow | |
| Had a daughter with Speedy | |
| Granddaughter of Red Tornado and member of the Justice Society | |
| Chipmunk-like member of the Green Lantern Corps | |
| Son of Animal Man | |
| Nathan Heywood, cousin of a Justice League Detroit member | |
|