| Dawson was good for about 6 years before being horrible his last 6 or 7. Favre was good for about 15 years with about 5 down ones at the beginning and end. He had a better peak than anyone not named Manning on this list, and his career QB rating is higher than anyone on this list not named Manning, Montana, Young, or Graham. And he played far longer than any of these guys, which is far more valuable. And you never addressed Young being awful at the beginning of his career in Tampa. Why is he exempt? Just admit you have a vendetta against Favre, because there is no logical way to keep him out of the top 10. Either he is in because of accumulation, peak, or efficiency. Throw in a Super Bowl and 3 MVP's and he's got it all covered. |
Tecmo SB QBs 
Deepest Oceans and Seas 
Hall of Fame QBs
