| Question | Over/Under | Actual Number |
| Members of the Fellowship: 7 | |
| Rings given to the Elves: 5 | |
| Rings given to the Dwarf Lords: 10 | |
| Years taken to write The Fellowship: 17 | |
| Gollum's Age: 689 | |
| Age of J.R.R.Tolkien when The Fellowship is published: 45 | |
| Year of first publication of The Fellowship: 1973 | |
| Frodo's date of birthday: 26th | |
| Istari (Wizards) sent to Middle Earth: 3 | |
| Number of chapters in all three volumes: 54 | |
| Age in which the books take place: 7th | |
| Treebeard's age: 14303 | |
| Children of Elrond: 2 | |
| Length of Return of the King in minutes: 189 | |
| Number of Nazguls: 12 | |
| Age at death of Old Took: 113 | |
| % profit generated for New Line on initial outlay from Return of the King: 365 | |
| Number of Oscars won by Fellowship of the Ring: 10 | |
| Different people to hold the One Ring: 6 | |
| Number of meals Hobbits eat per day: 5 | |
| Members of the Fellowship: 7 | |
| Rings given to the Elves: 5 | |
| Rings given to the Dwarf Lords: 10 | |
| Years taken to write The Fellowship: 17 | |
| Gollum's Age: 689 | |
| Age of J.R.R.Tolkien when The Fellowship is published: 45 | |
| Year of first publication of The Fellowship: 1973 | |
| Frodo's date of birthday: 26th | |
| Istari (Wizards) sent to Middle Earth: 3 | |
| Number of chapters in all three volumes: 54 | |
| Age in which the books take place: 7th | |
| Treebeard's age: 14303 | |
| Children of Elrond: 2 | |
| Length of Return of the King in minutes: 189 | |
| Number of Nazguls: 12 | |
| Age at death of Old Took: 113 | |
| % profit generated for New Line on initial outlay from Return of the King: 365 | |
| Number of Oscars won by Fellowship of the Ring: 10 | |
| Different people to hold the One Ring: 6 | |
| Number of meals Hobbits eat per day: 5 | |