| Who... | Player | Extra |
| ... played a two games in a day, each game for a different team. | |
| ... hit an NL pennant winning home run in 1951 to bring the Giants to the World Series? | |
| ... hit his record 715th home run to break the Babe's record? | |
| ... hit a home run in game 1 of the 1988 World Series to win the game? | |
| ... threw a no-hitter for the Red Sox in 2007 as the Red Sox routed the Orioles, 10-0? | |
| ... are the two National League pitchers to win a Triple Crown three times? (name one) | |
| ... was the last player to turn an unassisted triple play? | |
| ... threw a no-hitter for the Yankees - with no right hand? | |
| ... hit two grand slams in an inning for the Cardinals in 1999? | |
| ... threw a no-hitter in his first postseason start? | |