| I think I've spotted a flaw in this puzzle, but (since I enjoyed it immensly nonetheless), I would welcome someone to point out my mistake :) As far as I see it, if Sirius Black was the only one to cast 'Sporclamus' and cure only one victim, then Ron Weasley should also be a victim; Greyback is a victim, but one cured by Mad-eye (otherwise Hermione's clue doesn't work). This being the case, it would appear that Umbridge only cures Neville (Greyback doesn't need curing twice). As such, Umbridge also only cures one victim... Is this a flaw? It certainly seems it. |