Can you name the MLB Hall of Very Good?

created by Suffron_SD
  • Enter a player (last names acceptable) in the box below
  • Correctly named players will show up below
  • Answers do not have to be guessed in order
  • Source: Baseball Reference
  • Same number of players at each position as in the MLB HOF (excl. Negro Leagues). Fill the slots with the top eligible, non-HOF players (by WAR). Listed by team and POS where most valuable. *-HOF Mgr
  • This quiz has not been verified by Sporcle
18:00
Show Missed Answers  
Catcher
55.6/ATL (1960-77) 
50.4/STL (1968-88) 
48.7/OAK (1969-83) 
43.8/PHA (1913-31) 
43.4/NYY (1969-79) 
43.3/DET (1961-76) 
43.1/BOS (1871-90) 
40.6/KCR (1971-87) 
38.0/DTN (1878-93) 
35.7/DET (1977-95) 
35.1/TEX (1974-89) 
31.9/PHI (1884-1900) 
31.3/PIT (1949-67) 
First Base
79.9/HOU (1991-2005) 
66.0/TEX (1986-2005) 
63.1/OAK (1986-2001) 
61.2/PHI (1963-77) 
61.0/STL (1974-90) 
57.6/SF (1986-2000) 
56.8/TOR (1989-2005) 
52.9/DET (1958-74) 
50.5/TOR (1986-2004) 
44.9/STL (1907-21) 
44.6/BRO (1943-63) 
43.7/WSH (1915-34) 
43.0/BRO (1933-45) 
42.8/BSN (1894-1911) 
40.5/BRO (1912-27) 
39.8/NYY (1982-95) 
39.7/BAL (1961-77) 
38.5/PHA (1895-1917) 
Second Base
69.7/DET (1977-95) 
67.6/CAL (1970-86) 
60.5/NYY (1975-92) 
48.2/DET (1982-99) 
47.2/CLV (1888-1901) 
47.2/NYG (1907-20) 
44.4/WSH (1925-41) 
41.2/MIN (1991-2002) 
40.8/SLB (1912-24) 
40.6/TEX (1982-2007) 
40.6/BUF (1879-92) 
40.0/NYY (1951-60) 
39.3/LAD (1972-87) 
39.1/LAD (1953-66) 
38.7/CIN (1933-48) 
38.1/BRO (1943-53) 
36.4/PHA (1924-35) 
*35.7/STL (1904-16) 
Third Base
67.2/SEA (1987-2004) 
61.6/NYY (1967-88) 
60.8/TEX (1972-89) 
60.6/OAK (1966-81) 
58.4/STL (1955-69) 
57.3/ATL (1969-89) 
55.5/CHW (1989-2004) 
54.8/CHC (1932-47) 
52.3/BSN (1939-53) 
52.0/LAD (1971-87) 
47.1/TEX (1969-1986) 
Shortstop
75.9/CHC (1891-1911) 
68.9/CIN (1986-2004) 
66.9/DET (1977-1996) 
58.7/IND (1879-95) 
46.1/CAL (1961-78) 
45.3/OAK (1964-83) 
44.6/BSN (1889-1904) 
43.5/SLB (1941-55) 
42.8/NYG (1909-22) 
40.4/NYY (1910-27) 
40.0/CLV (1887-99) 
39.6/TOR (1983-2001) 
38.6/NYG (1946-60) 
37.7/NYG (1927-46) 
37.2/DET (1908-23) 
35.6/BOS (1963-76) 
34.8/PIT (1986-2003) 
33.6/CIN (1970-88) 
33.4/LAD (1959-72) 
32.5/BAL (1965-82) 
32.2/BOS (1899-1911) 
Left Field
64.6/MON (1979-2002) 
59.1/PHI (1904-19) 
53.2/PHA (1933-45) 
52.8/CHW (1949-80) 
52.2/HOU (1970-88) 
51.8/BRO (1897-1913) 
49.4/CAL (1973-92) 
46.8/PHA (1880-93) 
45.1/NYG (1911-25) 
44.9/CHC (1885-1903) 
44.5/NYY (1965-79) 
44.0/BRO (1934-49) 
43.6/DET (1912-25) 
43.4/NYY (1939-52) 
42.5/CIN (1969-86) 
39.4/NYG (1941-55) 
39.4/WSA (1958-73) 
39.0/KCR (1976-94) 
37.4/CLE (1989-2000) 
37.3/SLB (1915-29) 
Center Field
59.8/HOU (1963-77) 
57.2/LAD (1960-79) 
52.2/HOU (1970-86) 
50.9/PIT (1898-1918) 
49.9/DET (1975-90) 
49.3/CIN (1958-75) 
47.9/BOS (1987-2004) 
47.8/CHW (1896-1915) 
47.3/BOS (1974-90) 
46.5/CLE (1981-97) 
45.9/CHC (1879-92) 
45.2/BRO (1887-98) 
45.1/NYG (1887-1903) 
44.2/ATL (1976-93) 
42.8/PHI (1899-1911) 
41.8/PRO (1872-91) 
41.6/PIT (1983-95) 
Right Field
67.3/COL (1989-2005) 
63.4/BOS (1966-82) 
61.8/BOS (1972-91) 
57.0/SF (1968-81) 
55.0/SF (1975-92) 
46.4/CLE (1955-68) 
45.9/NYG (1887-99) 
45.2/MON (1963-85) 
45.1/BRO (1931-49) 
42.9/NYM (1983-99) 
42.4/MIN (1962-76) 
41.8/OAK (1985-2001) 
41.2/NYY (1930-46) 
40.6/BAL (1970-84) 
39.8/NYY (1957-68) 
39.7/ATL (1989-2002) 
39.4/ATL (1958-74) 
39.0/CHC (1936-53) 
37.8/PIT (1973-91) 
37.6/NYY (1937-50) 
37.1/DET (1979-95) 
37.0/CHW (1980-2001) 
36.4/LOU (1882-94) 
You might also like these games:
MLB Hall of Famers   MLB World Series Droughts   MLB Wins Leaders per Team (2000s)
There are 25 comments for this game.
(Warning: comments may contain spoilers)

MLB Hall of Very Good (Position Players) Quiz

  1. by Suffron_SD
  • Created May 22, 2011 in Sports
  • Game Plays 3,157

Friend Scores and Standings

Loading friend results....