| Clue | Player |
| That guy who had the game-winning hit in game 6 of the 1985 World Series (Denkinger game) | |
| The Phillies moved Mike Schmidt to 1B because of this guy, a future star at 3B...or not | |
| That guy who was a one-year wonder for the Indians, winning the 1980 AL Rookie of the Year | |
| That guy who also played LF for the Indians in 1980, hitting .341 with 61 steals... but was out of baseball 5 years later | |
| That lefthanded pitcher who won 18 games for the surprise '89 Orioles and 13 the rest of his career | |
| That guy who clinched the NL West for the Astros with a no-hitter in 1986 | |
| That guy (who was a former Seattle All-Star) who hit a HR in the first Wrigley night game for the Phillies, which was ultimately rained out | |
| That guy who used the 'one-flap down' style in his homerun trot during the 1987 NLCS | |
| That guy who set a stolen base record for catchers for the Royals in 1982 | |
| That guy who was in the second Oak-NYY Rickey Henderson deal who ended up doing time for statutory rape | |
| That Angels closer who gave up a crucial home run in the 1986 ALCS--an event that tragically haunted him until his suicide in 1989 | |
| The White Sox briefly moved Carlton Fisk to LF because of this guy, a future star catcher...or not | |
| The guy who was third in MLB in 1986 with 35 HR and never played again | |
| That guy whose miscue allowed the tying run to score in the 10th inning of game 6 of the 1986 World Series | |
| That guy who won 20 games as a rookie in '85 and threw a perfect game in '88 | |
| That guy who gave up Pete Rose's record-breaking hit and two years later started a bench-clearing brawl by beaning Andre Dawson in the face | |