| Team Hint | Team Rhyme | Rhyme Hint |
| Formerly Devil (Tampa Bay) | |
| An art museum or “How I ___ Your Mother” (New York) | |
| The color of rust (Cincinnati) | |
| Go Go Power (Texas) | |
| A type of snake in the southwest or a turtle in the midatlantic(Arizona) | |
| Chain of mountains (Colorado) | |
| Like the Tudors (Kansas City) | |
| Father in Spanish (San Diego) | |
| Jack Sparrow's mates in the Caribbean (Pittsburgh) | |
| Jack's adversary upon the beanstalk (San Francisco) | |
| Half of a Liger (Detroit) | |
| They're In the Outfield (Los Angeles/Anaheim) | |
| This team was formerly in Montreal (Washington) | |
| Jetsons dog (Houston) | |
| Sky colored birds notorious for protective mothers | |
| A large edible billfish (Florida) | |
| Pull (New York) | |
| Beer maker (Milwaukee) | |
| Orange Birds (Baltimore) | |
| Gemini (Minnesota) | |
| A shifty or dishonest person (Los Angeles) | |
| One who navigates a ship (Seattle) | |
| The elect the Pope (St. Louis) | |
| Bloody Footwear (Boston) | |
| Native Americans (Cleveland) | |
| Baby bear (Chicago) | |
| An attribute of athletes (Oakland) | |
| The Phanatic is their mascot (Philadelphia) | |
| Bleached Bloody Footwear (Chicago) | |
| Fearless People (Atlanta) | |