| Year/Team/League/Position | Player |
| 1877-Boston Red Caps-NL-P | |
| 1878-Providence Grays-NL-OF | |
| 1884-Providence Grays-NL-P | |
| 1884-Louisville Eclipse-AL-P | |
| 1887-St. Louis Browns-AL-OF | |
| 1888-New York Giants-NL-P | |
| 1889-Boston Beaneaters-NL-P | |
| 1894-New York Giants-NL-P | |
| 1894-Boston Beaneaters-NL-OF | |
| 1901-Boston Americans-AL-P | |
| 1901-Philadelphia Athletics-AL-2B | |
| 1905-New York Giants-NL-P | |
| 1905-Philadelphia Athletics-AL-P | |
| 1908-New York Giants-NL-P | |
| 1909-Detroit Tigers-AL-CF | |
| 1913-Washington Senators-AL-P | |
| 1915-Philadelphia Phillies-NL-P | |
| 1916-Philadelphia Phillies-NL-P | |
| 1918-Chicago Cubs-NL-P | |
| 1918-Washington Senators-AL-P | |
| 1920-Chicago Cubs-NL-P | |
| 1922-St. Louis Cardinals-NL-2B | |
| 1924-Brooklyn Robins-NL-P | |
| 1924-Washington Senators-AL-P | |
| 1925-St. Louis Cardinals-NL-2B | |
| 1930-Philadelphia Athletics-AL-P | |
| 1931-Philadelphia Athletics-AL-P | |