| Year/Team/League/Position | Player |
| 1931 - Philadelphia Athletics - AL - P | |
| 1933 - Philadelphia Phillies - NL - OF | |
| 1933 - Philadelphia Athletics - NL - 1B | |
| 1934 - New York Yankees - AL - P | |
| 1934 - New York Yankees - AL - 1B | |
| 1937 - New York Yankees - AL - P | |
| 1937 - St. Louis Cardinals - NL - LF | |
| 1939 - Cincinnati Reds - NL - P | |
| 1940 - Cleveland Indians - AL - P | |
| 1942 - Boston Red Sox - AL - LF | |
| 1945 - Detroit Tigers - AL - P | |
| 1947 - Boston Red Sox - AL - LF | |
| 1956 - New York Yankees - AL - CF | |
| 1963 - Los Angeles Dodgers - NL - P | |
| 1965 - Los Angeles Dodgers - NL - P | |
| 1966 - Los Angeles Dodgers - NL - P | |
| 1966 - Baltimore Orioles - AL - OF | |
| 1967 - Boston Red Sox - AL - LF | |
| 1972 - Philadelphia Phillies - NL - P | |
| 1985 - New York Mets - NL - P | |
| 1997 - Toronto Blue Jays - AL - P | |
| 1998 - Toronto Blue Jays - AL - P | |
| 1999 - Boston Red Sox - AL - P | |
| 2002 - Arizona Diamondbacks - NL - P | |
| 2006 - Minnesota Twins - AL - P | |
| 2007 - San Diego Padres - NL - P | |