| Hint | Character |
| Little red monster with his own TV show | |
| Loves trash and grumpiness | |
| Lives in a trash can with an elephant | |
| An avid pigeon lover and paperclip collector | |
| Loves bathtime with his rubber ducky | |
| COOKIE!!!!! | |
| Muppet original famous for 'The Rainbow Connection' | |
| Big. Yellow. Flightless...(presumably) | |
| member of the Triangle Lovers Association | |
| Depressed woolly mammoth | |
| Sesame street's answer to Hannah Montana | |
| Her best friends include a pet rock and a red muppet | |
| 1! Ah ah ah! 2! Ah ah ah! | |
| Frequently fainting monster with varying occupations including waiter and superhero | |
| Husky voiced host of 'Monster Hits!' | |