| Hint | Player Name | Team(s) most connected to |
| Starting catcher for the 2005 Championship Chicago White Sox | |
| Struck out three batters on nine pitches in a half-inning (1991) | |
| Only pitcher to record a four strikeout inning in his major league debut | |
| His home run off Dave McNally tied game 5 of the 1969 World Series | |
| 1988 AL Cy Young Award winner | |
| Silver Slugger Award winning shortstop (1995) | |
| 2002 AL Rolaids Relief Man of the Year | |
| Recorded all 3,060 career hits for the Houston Astros | |
| 1967 AL MVP | |
| Current starting pitcher who has spent his entire career with the Washington Nationals | |
| 2009 NL All-Star starting pitcher | |