| Hint | Name in My Immortal |
| A fukin prep | |
| Nevil Longbottom | |
| Harry Potter | |
| The main character! | |
| Caretaker | |
| The villain | |
| Sales man | |
| Peter Pettigrew | |
| Ex-Professor and pedo | |
| The author | |
| Ginny Weasley | |
| Transfiguration Professor | |
| Ron Weasley | |
| | Hint | Name in My Immortal |
| Headmaster and Poser | |
| The boyfriend | |
| The villain's lover | |
| Hermione Granger | |
| Rubeus Hagrid | |
| Cat | |
| Pedo and Masticator | |
| Minister of Magic | |
| Professor Trelawney | |
| The authors friend | |
| Back to the future! | |
| Professor Sinistra | |
| The best friend | |
|