| Years Played (Main Team) | Player | Rank (among all players) |
| 1951-1968 (Yankees) | |
| 1999-Present (Astros) | |
| 2003-Present (Rangers) | |
| 1993-Present (Braves) | |
| 1998-Present (Royals) | |
| 1931-1941 (Cardinals) | |
| 1966-1982 (Red Sox) | |
| 1995-2009 (Tigers) | |
| 1995-Present (Yankees) | |
| 1991-2006 (Yankees) | |
| | Years Played (Main Team) | Player | Rank (among all players) |
| 1977-1997 (Orioles) | |
| 1996-2008 (Tigers) | |
| 1986-2001 (Pirates) | |
| 2002-Present (Indians) | |
| 1993-2006 (Mets) | |
| 1981-1999 (Angels) | |
| 1986-2006 (Rangers) | |
| 1984-1997 (Tigers) | |
| 1992-2007 (Brewers) | |
| 1987-2001 (Astros) | |
|