| Player Choices | Player | Weights |
| Martin Gramatica or Pat Williams? | |
| Leonard Davis or Tom Brady? | |
| Peyton Manning or Bernard Berrian? | |
| Ronnie Brown or Kellen Winslow? | |
| Terrell Owens or Randy Moss? | |
| Osi Umenyiora or Albert Haynesworth? | |
| LaDainian Tomlinson or Adrian Peterson (Vikings)? | |
| Troy Polamalu or Darren Sharper? | |
| 0/8: You lost! I suggest you give up because you got it wrong. | |
| 1/8: You lost! I suggest you give up because you got it wrong. | |
| 2/8: You lost! I suggest you give up because you got it wrong. | |
| 3/8: You lost! I suggest you give up because you got it wrong. | |
| 4/8: You lost! I suggest you give up because you got it wrong. | |
| 5/8: You lost! I suggest you give up because you got it wrong. | |
| 6/8: You lost! I suggest you give up because you got it wrong. | |
| 7/8: You lost! I suggest you give up because you got it wrong. | |