| Hint | Agent | Show |
| This agent is a paranormal investigator with a brain full of Cortexiphan | |
| This agent knew that the truth was out there | |
| This agent only investigates elaborate cons | |
| This agent primarily works with his brother, a mathematical genius | |
| This agent ends up working with a mind reader to catch a serial killer | |
| This agent's death leads to an international incident involving the United States, Russia, and the Islamic Republic of Kamistan | |
| This agent lost his wife to a serial killer known as 'The Reaper' | |
| This agent solves most of his cases by working with 'squints' | |
| This agent has a long-standing relationship with the Navy and only grows a beard when he's going undercover | |
| This agent left the FBI to become a crime scene investigator | |
| This agent assists human polygraph machines | |
| This agent must follow an ex-spy and report on his actions | |