| Athlete | Last Name | Celebrity |
| Danica | |
| Steve | |
| Matt | |
| Eddie | |
| Tim | |
| Carl | |
| Reggie | |
| Byron | |
| Archie | |
| Eddie | |
| Evan | |
| Dwight | |
| Warren | |
| Darrell | |
| Dustan | |
| Oscar | |
| Honus | |
| Dizzy | |
| Tommy | |
| Alan | |
| Brian | |
| Norm | |
| Carl | |
| Reggie | |
| Kermit | |
| Pete | |
| Bart | |
| Isaiah | |
| Sidney | |
| Bud | |
| David | |
| Johnny | |
| Ray | |
| Patrick | |
| Marcus | |
| Tom | |
| Richard | |
| Allan | |
| | Athlete | Last Name | Celebrity |
| Harry | |
| Lamar | |
| Kenyon | |
| Vince | |
| Rick | |
| Mariano | |
| Tony | |
| Brett | |
| Dale | |
| Joe | |
| Matt | |
| Jimmy | |
| Wilt | |
| Derek | |
| John | |
| Mike | |
| Willie | |
| Derrick | |
| Bud | |
| Hines | |
| Ray | |
| Kenny | |
| Jim | |
| Willis | |
| Kevin | |
| Steve | |
| Delonte | |
| Rick | |
| Johan | |
| Mark | |
| Jimmie | |
| Dwight | |
| Bryce | |
| Edgerrin | |
| Jim | |
| Vernon | |
| Earl | |
| Michelle | |
| | Athlete | Last Name | Celebrity |
| Trent | |
| Paul | |
| Jamaal | |
| Franco | |
| Scot | |
| Mike | |
| Ken | |
| Grant | |
| Don | |
| Danny | |
| Karl | |
| Tiger | |
| Derrick | |
| Elton | |
| Ken | |
| Lleyton | |
| Brian | |
| Jermaine | |
| Chipper | |
| Al | |
| Richard | |
| Bo | |
| Philip | |
| Garrett | |
| Kobe | |
| Buster | |
| Lawrence | |
| Javy | |
| Lance | |
| Wilbur | |
| Len | |
| Trevor | |
| Corey | |
| David | |
| Jim | |
| Kirk | |
| O.J. | |
| Tug | |
|