| Hint | Answer |
| What is the name of Sam & Dean's grandmother? | |
| What was the name of Michael's vessel? | |
| How much older is Dean than Sam? | |
| What's the name of Jo's mother? | |
| Who was John's other son? | |
| In what episode did a little girl's teddy bear come to life? | |
| What was the name of Castiel's vessel? | |
| What angel does Dean have sex with in the back of the Impala? | |
| Who was the mullet-wearing computer genius? | |
| Where was Crowley's vessel buried? | |