| Main Team(s) Played For, Position, Stats | Player-There Are Five Repeat Foods |
| Mets, RF, .259/.357/.505 1983-1999 | |
| Yankees/Red Sox, SP, 240-162, 3.60 1912-1934 | |
| Cubs/Orioles, CF, .244/.305/.383, 2007- | |
| Dodgers, OF, .317/.367/.450 1909-1927 | |
| Cardinals, OF, .251/.307/.407 2009- | |
| Tigers/White Sox, CF, .273/.355/.442, 1975-1990 | |
| Red Sox, LF, .298/.352/.502 1974-1989 | |
| Indians, CF, .277/.331/.407 2002-2009 | |
| Tigers, SP, 170-161, 3.23 1939-1957 | |
| Cardinals, SP, 90-88, 3.85 1952-1962 | |
| Yankees/White Sox, RP, 124-107, 3.01 1972-1994 | |
| Blue Jays, SS, .249/.285/.319 1976-1993 | |
| Cubs, OF, .273/.336/.362 1942-1955 | |
| Phillies, 3B, .258/.343/.410 1947-1961 | |
| Senators, CF, .262/.332/.460, 1950-1963 | |
| Senators, OF, .322/.374/.427 1915-1934 | |
| White Sox, CF, .255/.308/.344 1962-1975 | |
| | Main Team(s) Played For, Position, Stats | Player-There Are Five Repeat Foods |
| Yankees, RP, 5-3, 3.74 2008- | |
| Cubs/Orioles, RP 1-4, 5.77 2007-2008 | |
| Pirates, 3B, .320/.362/.435 1920-1937 | |
| Giants, RF, .254/.322/.424 1981-1995 | |
| Giants/Angels, OF, .274/.360/.451 1981-1999 | |
| Senators, OF, .316/.387/.500 1921-1938 | |
| Cubs/White Sox, SP, 88-92, 4.18, 1978-1989 | |
| Cardinals, OF/3B, .298/.358/.443 1928-1944 | |
| Indians, SP, 55-46, 3.36 1955-1962 | |
| Tigers, OF, .366/.433/.512 1905-1928 | |
| Indians, SP, 207-128, 3.23 1941-1958 | |
| Astros/Rangers, 3B, .277/.333/.417 2000-2008 | |
| Phillies/Royals, 2B, .263/.306/.337 1962-1977 | |
| Athletics/Yankees, SP, 224-166, 3.26 1965-1979 | |
| Braves, SS, .258/.318/.340, 1912-1935 | |
| Angels, RF, .282/.385/.498 1992-2006 | |
|