| Hint | Player |
| This Cardinals great was better-known for his speed, but he also committed more errors in LF (167) than any other player. | |
| He had 3,255 hits and 504 HR, but he also hit 128 sacrifice flies, the most ever. | |
| This superstar was mostly known for his durability, but he also grounded into a record 350 double plays. | |
| This late Phillies great gave up more home runs (505) than any pitcher in history, though it's in danger of being broken by Jamie Moyer. | |
| This legend, synonymous with great pitching, faced more than 4,000 more batters than any other pitcher. | |
| In 2000, this 3-time Cy Young winner posted the lowest single-season WHIP (0.737) in history. | |
| This current Phillies star notched an astonishing 778 plate appearances in 2007. | |
| This legend reached base 379 times in a single season, a record that has stood for 87 years. | |
| | Hint | Player |
| This recently retired star reached base 331 times in 1999, the most for a righty. Amazingly, the 18 players above him on the list are lefties. | |
| This 4-time All Star, currently with the Red Sox, has won only one Gold Glove, but he has the highest career fielding percentage for a third baseman (.9743). | |
| The Red Sox have the corners covered, as this current player also has the highest career fielding percentage (.9976) for a first baseman. | |
| This current star has the highest career OPS (1.0528) for a right-handed batter. | |
| Considering this legend's other records, perhaps it's no surprise that he also made more outs (10,328) than any other player in MLB history. | |
| This oft-injured pitcher did his best to spread the pain, hitting 21 batters in 2003, the most in a season by any active hurler. | |
| This Diamondback set a record by striking out 204 times in 2008, only to best it the next year by whiffing 223 times. | |
|