| Question | Answer |
| Who stole a blue French horn? | |
| What does Barney do a musical number about? | |
| What are the waitress and bartender's names at MacLaren's? | |
| What fruit does Ted wake up with after a drunken night? | |
| What's Barney's nickname for himself? | |
| What did Marshall accidentally shoot into Lily's eye? | |
| Where was Stella and Ted's wedding? | |
| Where does Robin go after she and Ted break up? | |
| Where did Lily move to take an art fellowship? | |
| What Star Wars character is in Barney's apartment? | |
| Who urged Lily to move back to New York? | |
| What is Barney's job? | |
| What part of 'the mother' has Ted seen? | |
| What is Ted's sister's name? | |
| Who is Robin's favorite musician? | |
| Who was Lily's highschool boyfriend? | |
| Who attends 'Robots vs. Wrestlers'? | |
| What is Robin's job? | |