| Draft Info (College and Position) | Bust | Potential Alternatives |
| #1 pick in 1995 by Cincinnati (Penn State running back) | |
| #2 pick in 1998 by San Diego (Washington State quarterback) | |
| #3 pick in 1998 by Arizona (Florida State defensive end) | |
| #5 pick in 1998 by Chicago (Penn State running back) | |
| #1 pick in 1999 by Cleveland (Kentucky quarterback) | |
| #3 pick in 1999 by Cincinnati (Oregon quarterback) | |
| #1 pick in 2000 by Cleveland (Penn State defensive end) | |
| #4 pick in 2000 by Cincinnati (Florida State wide receiver) | |
| | Draft Info (College and Position) | Bust | Potential Alternatives |
| #1 pick in 2002 by Houston (Fresno State quarterback) | |
| #3 pick in 2002 by Detroit (Oregon quarterback) | |
| #2 pick in 2003 by Detroit (Michigan State wide receiver) | |
| #4 pick in 2003 by New York Jets (Kentucky defensive tackle) | |
| #1 pick in 2005 by San Francisco (Utah quarterback) | |
| #2 pick in 2006 by New Orleans (USC running back) [note: I realize there is some debate about this one, but I think it's safe to say he has not lived up to the hype so far] | |
| #1 pick in 2007 by Oakland (LSU quarterback) | |
|