| Year/Team | | On-Base Percentage |
| Oakland, 2000 | |
| Toronto, 2000 | |
| Cleveland, 2000 | |
| Chicago White Sox, 2000 | |
| Boston, 2000 | |
| Seattle, 2000 | |
| Seattle, 2000 | |
| New York Yankees, 2000 | |
| New York Yankees, 2000 | |
| Anaheim, 2000 | |
| Kansas City, 2000 | |
| Minnesota, 2000 | |
| Anaheim, 2000 | |
| Anaheim, 2000 | |
| Minnesota, 2000 | |
| Oakland, 2001 | |
| Seattle, 2001 | |
| Cleveland, 2001 | |
| Cleveland, 2001 | |
| Toronto, 2001 | |
| Boston, 2001 | |
| Seattle, 2001 | |
| | Year/Team | | On-Base Percentage |
| Boston, 2002 | |
| Cleveland, 2002 | |
| New York Yankees, 2002 | |
| Kansas City, 2002 | |
| New York Yankees, 2002 | |
| Toronto, 2002 | |
| Seattle, 2002 | |
| Boston, 2003 | |
| Toronto, 2003 | |
| New York Yankees, 2003 | |
| Seattle, 2003 | |
| New York Yankees, 2003 | |
| Baltimore, 2004 | |
| Seattle, 2004 | |
| Cleveland, 2004 | |
| New York Yankees, 2004 | |
| New York Yankees, 2005 | |
| New York Yankees, 2005 | |
| Cleveland, 2005 | |
| Boston, 2006 | |
| Cleveland, 2006 | |
| Minnesota, 2006 | |
| | Year/Team | | On-Base Percentage |
| New York Yankees, 2006 | |
| Chicago White Sox, 2006 | |
| New York Yankees, 2006 | |
| Boston, 2006 | |
| Detroit, 2006 | |
| Boston, 2007 | |
| Detroit, 2007 | |
| New York Yankees, 2007 | |
| New York Yankees, 2007 | |
| Tampa Bay, 2007 | |
| Chicago White Sox, 2007 | |
| Oakland, 2007 | |
| Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim, 2007 | |
| Texas, 2008 | |
| Minnesota, 2008 | |
| Baltimore, 2008 | |
| Minnesota, 2009 | |
| Boston, 2009 | |
| New York Yankees, 2009 | |
| Tampa Bay, 2009 | |
| New York Yankees, 2009 | |
|