| Hint | Pair |
| Really big spiders | |
| Swords from the Trolls hoard | |
| The sons of Denethor | |
| At the gate of Cirith Ungol | |
| Two trees of Valinor | |
| Theodens adopted kin | |
| Two towers | |
| Sam's names for Gollum | |
| They stole a Silmaril | |
| | Hint | Pair |
| Black swords forged by Eol | |
| Annoying Sackville Baggins | |
| Elves that obeyed the summons, and those that did not | |
| Telepathic races | |
| Kings at Argonath | |
| Barliman Butterbur employees | |
| Sons of Elrond | |
| Frodo's fellowship pals | |
| BONUS: Faramirs rangers of Ithilien | |
|