| 2012 Team (*2011 Team) | Player | Career WAR |
| NYY | |
| LAA | |
| ATL (retired October 2012) | |
| NYY | |
| PHI/BAL | |
| CIN | |
| OAK (didn't play in a game in 2012) | |
| StL | |
| PHI | |
| TEX | |
| NYY | |
| COL | |
| LAA/LAD | |
| BAL* | |
| SEA/NYY | |
| NYY | |
| PHI | |
| NYY | |
| CLE | |
| ATL | |
| NYY | |
| NYM | |
| StL | |
| TEX | |
| MIA | |
| COL | |
| NYY | |
| COL | |
| DET | |
| LAA | |
| SF* | |
| MIA | |
| TOR (retired October 2012) | |
| PHI | |
| | 2012 Team (*2011 Team) | Player | Career WAR |
| NYM | |
| PHI | |
| KC* (officially retired July 2012) | |
| StL | |
| MIN | |
| BOS | |
| OAK | |
| StL | |
| NYY | |
| NYY | |
| CHW | |
| DET | |
| BOS/LAD | |
| PHI | |
| MIL | |
| NYY | |
| StL | |
| NYY | |
| SEA | |
| CLE/NYY | |
| BOS/LAD | |
| SF | |
| BOS | |
| LAA | |
| BOS/CHW | |
| MIL/LAA | |
| MIA | |
| SF | |
| TEX | |
| WAS | |
| LAD | |
| SD/CHW | |
| TB | |
| PHI | |
| | 2012 Team (*2011 Team) | Player | Career WAR |
| BOS/LAD | |
| MIL | |
| LAA | |
| ATL/MIL | |
| CLE | |
| BAL | |
| CIN | |
| CHC (retired May 2012) | |
| MIA/LAD | |
| SEA | |
| COL | |
| LAA | |
| TB | |
| CHW | |
| DET | |
| LAD | |
| HOU/MIA | |
| CHC | |
| MIA | |
| LAD | |
| TEX | |
| TB | |
| CHW | |
| PHI/LAD | |
| BOS | |
| TEX | |
| CLE | |
| PIT | |
| BOS (didn't play in a game in 2012) | |
| TEX | |
| MIL/BAL | |
| NYM | |
| OAK | |
|