| Year | Player | Team |
| 1920 WS | |
| 1936 WS | |
| 1951 WS | |
| 1953 WS | |
| 1956 WS | |
| 1956 WS | |
| 1960 WS | |
| 1962 WS | |
| 1964 WS | |
| 1964 WS | |
| 1968 WS | |
| 1970 ALCS | |
| 1970 WS | |
| 1977 NLCS | |
| 1977 NLCS | |
| 1982 ALCS | |
| 1987 WS | |
| 1987 WS | |
| 1988 WS | |
| 1989 NLCS | |
| 1992 NLCS | |
| 1992 WS | |
| 1995 NLDS | |
| 1995 ALDS | |
| 1996 ALDS | |
| 1996 ALDS | |
| 1996 NLCS | |
| | Year | Player | Team |
| 1997 NLDS | |
| 1997 ALDS | |
| 1998 NLDS | |
| 1998 NLDS | |
| 1998 NLCS | |
| 1998 ALCS | |
| 1998 WS | |
| 1999 NLDS | |
| 1999 ALDS | |
| 1999 ALDS | |
| 1999 ALCS | |
| 2003 NLCS | |
| 2004 ALDS | |
| 2004 ALCS | |
| 2005 NLDS | |
| 2005 NLDS | |
| 2005 NLDS | |
| 2005 WS | |
| 2007 NLDS | |
| 2007 ALCS | |
| 2008 NLDS | |
| 2008 NLDS | |
| 2011 ALDS | |
| 2011 NLDS | |
| 2011 NLDS | |
| 2011 ALCS | |
|