| Hint | Player Name |
| #1 | |
| #2 | |
| #3 | |
| #4 | |
| #5 | |
| #6 | |
| #7 | |
| #8 | |
| #9 | |
| #10 | |
| Teammate of #10 for the 1996 Braves | |
| Signed with #8's team in 2008, played with #3 in 2009 and was a teammate of #10 from 1996-2007 - also has the same last name as #10 so if you got this you probably got him | |
| Began his career playing on #10's lifetime team and pitched a few games to #3 in 2009 | |
| Began pitching for #10's team in 2000 and has played with #1, #2, #3 and #4 | |
| Won 21 games for #10's team in 2004 | |
| Played with #10 for five and a half seasons | |
| Teammate of #10's from 2005-2009 | |
| The catcher for #10's team | |
| Teammate of #10's in 2008, #1's in 2004 and 2005 and #9's in 2009 | |
| The former 2B for #10's team | |
| Teammate of #10 from 2005-2010 | |
| Played 88 games with #10 and 22 games with #6 in 2008 | |
| Played 43 games with #10 and 39 games with #6 in 2008 | |
| Pitcher for #10's team | |
| A former teammate of #2 who joined #10's team in 2009 after playing with #2 for four seasons and joined #8's team in 2010 | |
| Played with #9 in 2009 and #10 in 2010 | |
| Phenom who joined #10's team in 2010 | |
| Sinkerballer who played with #6 from 1997 to 2004, #8 from 2006-2008 and #10 from 2009 to 2010 | |
| Pitcher for #10's team | |
| Played with #9 for two seasons | |
| Played with #9 for one season and #3 for one season and #5 for one season | |
| Used to play for #9's current team but now plays for #9's old team | |
| Former nutcase teammate of #5 and former teammate of #9 | |
| Played with #6 from 2006-2008 and with #s 5 and 9 from 2002-2005 | |
| Teammate of #s 5 and 9 with the Cleveland Indians | |
| Caught for #5 and #9 for eight seasons, then for #6 | |
| Shares a last name with #5 | |
| Shares a last name with #5 and is a former teammate of #1 | |
| Played five seasons with #5 and five seasons with #9 | |
| Teammate of #5's for six seasons and of #9's for six seasons | |
| Only played 135 games over four seasons while on #s 5 and 9's former team | |
| Former teammate of #s 3, 5 and 9 and his injury resulted in the trade of #1 | |
| Played with both #5 and #9 for three seasons | |
| Played with #5 and #9 in Cleveland and then #5 again in Seattle | |
| Played with #5 and #9 for three seasons | |
| Played with #6 from 1996 until 2006, when he signed with the team of #s 5 and 9 | |
| Played with #5 and #9 for six seasons | |
| Played with #5 and #9 for three seasons | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season | |
| Teammate of #9's with the Milwaukee Brewers for one season but has also played with #6's current team and won the NLCS MVP while playing with #2 | |
| Was traded for #9 in 2008 | |
| Was traded for #9 in 2008 | |
| Was traded for #9 in 2008 | |
| Was traded for #9 in 2008 | |
| Won the World Series with #9, played with #1 from 1999 to 2003 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Won the World Series with #9, was traded for #1 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Won the World Series with #9, played with #1 from 1999 to 2003 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Won the World Series with #9 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Won the World Series with #9, played with #1 in 2003 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Won the World Series with #9 | |
| Won the World Series with #9 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Won the World Series with #9 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Won the World Series with #9 | |
| Won the World Series with #9 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Teammate of #8 since 2006 | |
| Won the World Series with #9 and a former teammate of #2's with the Blue Jays | |
| Won the World Series with #9 and played with #3 in 2008 | |
| Dodger teammate of #8 | |
| Teammate of #6 and former teammate of #8 | |
| Traded to #8's team from #6's team in 2008 | |
| Has played with #5, #8 and #9 | |
| Currently plays directly to the left of #7 | |
| Lost the 2006 NLCS to #2's team but won 32 games while playing with #7 after winning 117 while playing with #6 but before winning 5 games with #5 and finishing 2nd in AL MVP voting | |
| Former star CFer for the same team as #7, which lost the NLCs to #2 in 2006 | |
| Former closer with #7 and with #10 | |
| Ace for #7's NL team | |
| Has some trouble catching for #6 | |
| Won the World Series with #6 in 2004 and with #9 in 2009 | |
| Manned SS for #6's team in 2004 | |
| Current ace of #6's team and won the World Series MVP while playing with #3 | |
| Teammate of #6's since 2006 | |
| Teammate of #6 | |
| Teammate of #6 | |
| Teammate of #6 | |
| Teammate of #6 | |
| Teammate of #6 | |
| Was brought into Philadelphia to replace the loss of #5 and finished 2nd to #5 in the AL Cy Young Award voting in 2008 and is a former teammate of #2 | |
| Won the NL Cy Young the same year #5 won the AL version of the award | |
| Teammate of #5 for half a season and a World Series run and finished 2nd to #4 in NL MVP voting in 2008 | |
| Teammate of #5 for half a season and a World Series run | |
| Teammate of #5 for half a season and a World Series run | |
| Teammate of #5 for half a season and a World Series run | |
| Current teammate of #5 and won AL Rookie of the Year the same year that #4 won the NL version of the award, beating out #s 1, 2 and 9 in the voting | |
| Former teammate of #5 | |
| Former teammate of #5 | |
| Former teammate of #5 | |
| Was released from #4's team, signed with #6's team and was then traded to #10's team | |
| His arrival in St. Louis caused #4's switch from 3B to 1B | |
| Catches for #4's team and #2's former team | |
| Has played with #4 for seven seasons and played with #2 for three seasons | |
| Has played with #4 for six seasons and #2 for three seasons | |
| Finished 2nd to #4 in NL MVP voting in 2009 | |
| Won the World Series with #3 in 2003 | |
| Won the World Series with #3 in 2003 | |
| Won the World Series with #3 in 2003 | |
| Played on the Tigers with #3 | |
| Was traded from #3's former team to #9's current team and lost the 2006 World Series to #2's team | |
| Pitched to #3 during his stop in Detroit | |
| Played with #3 for two and a half seasons | |
| Played with #3 in 2009 | |
| Played on the Astros with #3 | |
| Pitched a few games to #3 in 2008 and lost the 2001 NL Rookie of the Year award to #4 | |
| Pitched a few games to #3 in 2008 | |
| Teammate of #3's in 2009 | |
| Teammate of #3's in 2009 | |
| Teammate of #3's in 2009 and of #1's in 2004 and 2005 | |
| Teammate of #3's in 2009 and of #1's in 2004 and 2005 | |
| Plays on one of #3's former teams | |
| Plays on #3's current team and #1's former team | |
| Plays on one of #3's former teams | |
| Is a young phenom in the minor league system of #3's former team | |
| Former teammate of #2 | |
| Former teammate of #2 | |
| Former teammate of #2 | |
| Former teammate of #2 | |
| Former teammate of #2 | |
| Former teammate of #2 | |
| Was traded from #2's current team | |
| Former teammate of #2 | |
| Teammte of #1 | |
| Teammte of #1 | |
| Teammte of #1 | |
| Teammte of #1 | |
| Teammte of #1 | |
| Teammte of #1 | |
| Teammte of #1 | |
| Lost to #9's team in the 2009 ALDS | |
| Plays for #2's former team | |
| Plays in the same division as #6 and #9 | |
| Plays in the same division as #6 and #9 | |
| Lost the World Series in 2006 when #2 was the Series MVP | |
| Was a teammate of #3's in 2006 when they lost the World Series to #2 | |
| Was a teammate of #3's in 2006 when they lost the World Series to #2 | |
| Succeeded #2 as World Series MVP while playing with #6 | |
| Won the AL MVP the same year that #2 won the World Series MVP | |
| Plays in the same league and the same position as #4 and has one more Silver Slugger awards | |
| Was traded for #2 | |
| Played briefly with #2 in 2008 | |
| Played briefly with #2 in 2008 | |
| Played briefly with #2 in 2008 | |
| Played briefly with #2 in 2008 | |
| Played briefly with #2 in 2008 | |
| Played briefly with #2 in 2008 | |
| Played briefly with #2 in 2008 | |
| Played briefly with #2 in 2008 | |
| Current teammate of #6 | |
| Played with #2 in 2004 | |
| * | |